These caramels are absurdly good. Smooth, buttery, and perfectly balanced—sweet but not over the top, with flavors that actually taste like what they’re supposed to be.

The sea salt is a standout, the vanilla + toasted almond is deeply comforting, and the rotating seasonal flavor makes the whole box feel special. I planned to space them out… I did not succeed.

Buy two boxes. One to share, one to stash.

I was looking for a birthday present for my wife, who loves caramels. I also didn't want to buy a box of Brach's and call it a day. Supporting small businesses is important. I didn't realize exactly how small Sugar and Spoon actually was when I placed my order. The level of personal attention that I received from Anne on this small order was amazing. From making sure my birthday present was going to the right address, to the handwritten note that accompanied the order, it made me happy that I ordered from her.

Most importantly, my wife is beyond happy with the caramels.

I will definitely be supporting Anne at Sugar and Spoon in the future.

I’ve had many many caramels in my 77 years and these are the best. I will be ordering more for myself and my family.