My Signature Flavors

I make two core caramels year-round — simple, classic, and always in small batches.

  • Sea Salt (Best Seller!)
  • Vanilla + Toasted Almond
Shop All Caramels

Thoughtful Gifts That Make People Smile

From hostess gifts to birthdays to “just because,” my caramels are made to be shared.

Shop Gift Boxes

This Month’s Caramel

Vanilla — Slow cooked, buttery and golden - the caramel for the purist, made in a limited batch for April.

Available while it lasts.

Shop This Month’s Flavor

Why Sugar + Spoon

Handmade in small batches

Family recipe from the 1930s

Real ingredients, no preservatives

Soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture

Made in Paso Robles, California

A Family Recipe, Passed Down

These caramels began in my great-grandmother Edith’s kitchen in the 1930s.

For years, they were made only for holidays — wrapped by hand and shared with friends and family.

What started as a tradition is now a small business built on the same idea: make something thoughtful, and share it.

Read My Story

For Serious Caramel Lovers

Seasonal caramels delivered quarterly — including exclusive flavors you won’t always find in the shop.

Join the Caramel Club
99%
(346)
1%
(3)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
L
1/2 Pound Bundle - Two Pack ($4 savings)
Laura S.
Easter gift success

I bought 3 orders for my family and they were all thrilled to receive them. I got immediate thank you from the grandchildren with their favorites being the toasted almond. I'm waiting for next month's special, caramel with lavender! Thank you for your great customer service.

J
vanilla caramels - APRIL SEASONAL CARAMEL!
Jeni
DELISH TREATS!!!

These caramels are the perfect texture and soft chewiness without being sticky and gummy. The flavors are sublime with my favorites being Sea Salt and Vanilla Almond!
Thank You Anne for keeping tradition alive!

D
sea salt caramels - BEST SELLER!
Dina B
MELT IN YOUR MOUTH DREAMY CARAMELS

Well, we never say No to a good caramel, and these salted caramels were really some of the best we've had. Big buttery goodness that we had to hide to keep from disappearing. Expensive but worth it, Remember, you get what you pay for and these were high quality clean ingredients and we don't mind spending $ for it. Highly recommend!

123